View Print Friendly Version
The Devil Wears Prada: Criminals Involved in Fake Goods Are Often Involved in Human Trafficking
© Cheryl Hodgson 2010 | Posted on February 9, 2010
On January 11, 2010, National Human Trafficking Awareness Month was launched across the U.S. Human trafficking involves horrible mistreatment of children, with some abuses too difficult to even speak of, much less imagine. Did you ever wonder who makes those “cheap” GUCCI knockoffs? Those DKNY items on street corners? Many of them may well have involved child labor, some of them akin to slavery.
I recently chatted with a friend who is deeply involved in raising awareness of human trafficking through www.intent.com. I offered to share how intellectual property theft is tied to human trafficking by sophisticated criminals. My goal is for this piece to forever serve as a reminder to those of us who have been tempted to buy those inexpensive, counterfeit luxury handbags or watches. We are all aware of the issue, but until more informed, tend to think in terms of the big brand owner who is upset about loss of rights and profits. “So what’s the big deal?” Read this, and I hope you will think again before you buy.
I am an Intellectual Property attorney who has worked passionately in the field of trademark and copyright law for many years. Even I was completely sobered and sickened by a story I heard at a U.S. Trademark Office program here in Santa Monica a few years back. An American attorney based in Thailand spoke of his law firm’s involvement in verifying fake goods seized by Thai custom officials. This type of cooperation is a rather recent side cooperative effort, resulting more from terrorist concerns since 9/11 than a real concern about protecting luxury goods trademark owners. Discovery of the fake goods is a rather random event, since custom officials are routinely bribed to “look the other way.”
Imagine a horrible, unsafe, and unsanitary warehouse containing $20 million in state-of- the-art cigarette manufacturing equipment used to make fake cigarettes. Imagine criminals who have recruited unsuspecting youngsters to travel from China and beyond to “job fairs” seeking a better life. The innocent girls are sold into sexual slavery, and young men are chained to machines like the one in the cigarette plant, forced to do the work of criminal enterprise. In this case, a raid of the plant found the owners long gone, tipped off in advance by custom officials in Bangkok. All that remained were the young male teenagers, chained to the machines to which they were slaves.
A 2004 Time magazine post on the issue of fake bags pointed out the profit motive:
The machines that companies use as legitimate manufacturers are also available to the bad guys,” says Timothy Trainer, president of the International AntiCounterfeiting Coalition. The factories disguise the contents of containers with foodstuffs or other consumer products like lingerie. For those brave enough to risk it, it’s a spectacular investment, with as much as a 1,000% return–better than drug trafficking. A 40-ft. container filled with fake bags can turn a profit of $2 million to $4 million. And counterfeiters save the roughly 50% of that revenue that luxury houses would invest in innovation and marketing. Read More: The Purse-Party Blues
A June 2009 piece by Gary Jones appearing in Time brings home the reality of the enormity of the problem with a view of the Bangkok Museum of Counterfeit goods.
Clemence Gautier, a Bangkok attorney with Tilleke & Gibbins explains:
“People think, ‘Oh, it’s just a T shirt and it’s no real harm,’ but we try to explain where the money is going. What if a 10-year-old girl is working every day to make those T shirts?” Read more: Knock it Off: A Thai Museum for Counterfeit Goods
The writer’s own shame, like mine, and I hope yours, is inevitable once we acknowledge and understand the why and how such cheap prices come about. Counterfeit trademark goods involve large scale criminal activity, preying upon the most innocent of humanity to reap billions in profits. Please share this with others to spread the word. Together we can make a difference.
Cheryl Hodgson is a member of the Emerging Issues Committee of the International Trademark Association, and past president of the California Copyright Conference. Cheryl can be reached at www.hodgson-law.com. She posts regularly at the BRANDAIDE Blog. www.brandaideblog.com.
Technorati Tags: brand equity, brand management, brand protection, police your mark
4 Comments »
February 10th, 2010 at 5:57 am
What a great post this is. I have shared it with a bunch of my groups on LinkedIn and on Facebook as well as I think it points out the REAL COST OF COUNTERFEITING. I have friend in Thailand who has done a lot of anticounterfeiting work there and the stories he can tell about the use of child labor in Thailand in the manufacture of counterfeits would stand your hair on end (of course, most of the girls might be lucky to end up in factories; most of them end up in child prostitute houses). Please don’t buy counterfeit goods!
February 10th, 2010 at 10:11 am
[...] CLICK HERE to read the rest of the article… Cheryl Hodgson presently serves as a member of the Emerging Issues Committee of the International Trademark Association, and Past President of the California Copyright conference. She practices law in Santa Monica, CA and Cheryl can be reached at http://www.hodgson-law.com. Cheryl posts regularly at the BRANDAIDE Blog. http://www.brandaideblog.com Share and Enjoy: [...]
February 10th, 2010 at 11:56 am
[...] CLICK HERE to read the rest of the article… [...]
February 18th, 2010 at 1:21 pm
I think Cheryl brings out excellent points.This a fast growing issue.It is a multi-billion dollar industry.
I was reading other day that total number of people in “slavery” now a days a the largest ever. Even in USA.
Cheryl you are indeed doing a great service to humanity and should spearhead this movement to eradicate modern silent slavery.With your legal background and spiritual activism, nobody better than you